Family accuses former Gary councilman of involvement in wife's death
Family accuses former Gary councilman of involvement in wife's death
The family of a Gary woman found shot to death inside her home last year is accusing her husband of having a possible role in her death and demanding answers as he seeks a return to public office.
GARY, Ind. - The family of a Gary woman found shot to death inside her home last year is accusing her husband of having a possible role in her death and demanding answers as he seeks a return to public office.
Gary woman's death raises questions
The backstory:
Nicole Mabon-Brewer, 47, was found dead from a gunshot wound inside her home on Sept. 3, 2025. Her death remains classified as undetermined, and no criminal charges have been filed in connection with her death.
Her daughter, Kayla Green, and father, George Mabon, told FOX Chicago that Nicole had warned them years earlier that if anything happened to her, they should look to her husband, former Gary City Councilman Ron Brewer.
Green said her mother told several people that Brewer had threatened to kill her and make her death appear to be a suicide.
"My mom came to them and said that Ron said he would kill her, cover up and make it seem like she did herself and he would get away with it because of his connections," Green said. "She later confirmed it with me."
Green said she believes her mother’s death deserves a closer look. She also described Brewer as having a temper, saying she witnessed it while growing up.
"Ron has a temper. I’ve witnessed it a lot since I was younger. He’s been in my life since I was a toddler," she said.
The family said Nicole and Brewer had been together for more than 20 years, but their marriage had deteriorated. They said Nicole was planning to leave the marriage just weeks before her death.
Green also suggested tensions may have escalated after her mother learned information about Brewer’s private life.
Mabon said his daughter made similar warnings to him.
"She said if anything happens to me, Ron did it," he said. "She said he keeps making accusations about. I can kill you and I can get away with it."
Brewer, a former Gary councilman and council president, lost his seat in May. He is now seeking an appointment to fill a vacant position on the City Council.
Dig deeper:
Brewer has previously faced criminal allegations. In 2019, he pleaded not guilty to charges of kidnapping, confining and intimidating a 14-year-old boy he believed was involved in stealing his vehicle.
Police alleged Brewer tracked down the stolen vehicle in East Chicago, fired a gun at the teenagers inside and took the 14-year-old to Gary against his will.
Court records show the charges were later dropped after Brewer completed a six-month diversion program.
The family also questioned whether Brewer’s alleged connections to the Gary Police Department affected how Nicole’s death was handled. They said they did not feel comfortable bringing their concerns to the department.
Gary Mayor responds
What they're saying:
Gary Mayor Eddie Melton issued a statement on Thursday, saying the City of Gary is remaining separate from the investigative process and that he personally knew Nicole from high school.
"From the onset of this tragic incident, the City of Gary has made a deliberate decision to remain separate from the investigative process to ensure that there would be no actual or perceived conflict of interest. Our priority has been to allow an independent and impartial investigation to move forward without interference or influence from the City.
"Recognizing the importance of public trust, the City supported the request for the appointment of a Special Prosecutor, and the Lake County Prosecutor’s Office subsequently requested that the Indiana State Police assume responsibility for conducting the investigation. The Gary Police Department concurred with this decision, and the Indiana State Police has assumed full responsibility for leading the inquiry.
"The City’s position throughout this process has been consistent: this matter deserves an independent, thorough, and transparent investigation, and the appropriate investigative authorities must be afforded the opportunity to carry out their work without interference.
"On a personal level, this loss is especially heartbreaking for me. I knew Nicole Mabon-Brewer from our high school years, which makes this tragedy deeply personal. Beyond my responsibility as Mayor, I join her family, friends, and loved ones in mourning her passing. My heartfelt condolences are with everyone impacted by this loss. I recognize that her family and the community deserve answers, and I respect the investigative process as it moves forward.
"Because this remains an active investigation, the City will defer all investigative questions and requests for additional information to the Indiana State Police and the Lake County Prosecutor’s Office."
What's next:
FOX Chicago contacted the Gary Police Department by phone and email but did not receive a response.
Indiana State Police told FOX Chicago their investigation into Nicole’s death has been completed and submitted to the special prosecutor assigned to the case. The prosecutor is reviewing the investigation.
FOX Chicago repeatedly contacted Brewer and Gary City Council for comment but did not receive a response.
Nicole’s family is urging anyone with information about her death to come forward.
The Source: The information in this report came from interviews with Nicole Mabon-Brewer’s family, court records, Indiana State Police and outreach to the Gary Police Department, Ron Brewer and the Gary City Council.