DNA breakthrough leads to arrest in grisly 33-year-old Illinois cold case
Randy Gail Sperino was 34 years old when she was killed in rural Granite City, Illinois, in 1993. (Madison County State’s Attorney’s Office)
GRANITE CITY, Ill. - For more than three decades, the murder of Randy Gail Sperino haunted investigators in southern Illinois — a cold case centered on a young woman beaten to death and left in a rural field while her killer seemingly vanished without a trace.
Investigators spent decades chasing leads and revisiting evidence, but the case remained unsolved.
Now, prosecutors say a breakthrough in forensic genealogy and decades-old DNA evidence finally cracked the case wide open.
Madison County State’s Attorney Tom Haine announced first-degree murder charges Tuesday against Albert L. "Buddy" Zigler, 70, of Caseyville, in connection with Sperino’s 1993 killing, calling the arrest "an important step toward justice in a case that has remained unresolved for more than three decades."
"While nothing can erase the pain experienced by Miss Sperino’s loved ones, we hope this development provides some answers after so many years," Haine said in a statement.
Authorities say Sperino, 34, was found dead Nov. 9, 1993, in a field in unincorporated Granite City after suffering what court records describe as "massive blunt force trauma to the head."
Madison County State’s Attorney Tom Haine announces murder charges in the 1993 cold case killing of Randy Gail Sperino. (Madison County State’s Attorney’s Office)
For years, investigators chased leads, re-interviewed witnesses and repeatedly tested DNA evidence recovered during the original investigation, but the case remained unsolved.
That changed when investigators turned to forensic genealogical DNA, an advanced investigative technique that traces family connections through genetic evidence.
"This case demonstrates the extraordinary value of modern investigative tools such as forensic genealogical DNA," Haine said. "Advances in technology and science are creating opportunities to solve cases that, years ago, might never have been solved."
According to Haine, Madison County Sheriff Jeff Connor recognized the potential of forensic genealogy years before the technology became mainstream in cold case investigations.
"Seven years ago, Sheriff Connor had the foresight to know that a new investigative tool, even though it was just emerging, might be able to provide a breakthrough in this investigation," Haine said. "The sheriff and his investigators never wavered in seeking justice in this case."
Haine credited generations of investigators for refusing to let the case go cold for good.
Madison County Sheriff Jeff Connor discusses the forensic genealogy investigation that led to an arrest in the 1993 killing of Randy Gail Sperino. (Madison County State’s Attorney’s Office)
"These tools are only effective because of the dedication, persistence, and professionalism of investigators who are willing to revisit evidence, follow leads, knock on doors, conduct interviews and continue pursuing the truth, no matter how much time has passed," he said.
Court documents allege Zigler later admitted to investigators that he picked Sperino up in Granite City, beat her with a metal bat or steel pipe at his residence and dumped her body in a field.
Zigler has been charged with two counts of first-degree murder alleging he intentionally beat Sperino with a bludgeon, causing her death. Prosecutors are seeking to keep Zigler behind bars pending trial, arguing the charges involve a violent and non-probationable offense.
An arrest warrant filed in Madison County Circuit Court shows Zigler remains in custody.
Zigler has been charged with two counts of first-degree murder alleging he intentionally beat Sperino with a bludgeon, causing her death. Prosecutors are seeking to keep Zigler behind bars pending trial, arguing the charges involve a violent and non-probationable offense.
An arrest warrant filed in Madison County Circuit Court shows Zigler remains in custody.